Roth or traditional IRA: what decides it?
Choosing between a Roth and a traditional IRA comes down to one question: will your tax rate be higher now or in retirement? If it will be higher later, paying tax today through a Roth tends to win. If it will be lower later, the traditional IRA's upfront deduction tends to win. If the rates are equal, both end up about the same.
This Roth vs traditional IRA calculator tests that idea with numbers. You enter your age, retirement age, annual IRA contribution, current federal bracket, expected retirement bracket and an expected return. The comparison gives both sides the same take-home cost: the Roth side invests the amount you type, and the traditional side invests the larger pre-tax amount that costs the same, which is the contribution divided by one minus your current rate.
Each balance grows with yearly compounding. The traditional balance is then reduced by your retirement rate, while the Roth balance is not. For example, $7,000 a year for 35 years at 7%, with a 22% rate now and 12% later, gives about $1,035,000 for Roth and $1,168,000 after tax for traditional. The model is simple. It ignores state tax, deduction eligibility and contribution limits, and it is general information, not tax advice.
How to compare a Roth and a traditional IRA
- Enter Current Age and Retirement Age. The difference is the number of years of saving.
- Type the yearly amount in Annual IRA Contribution ($). For 2026 the IRA limit is $7,500, or $8,600 if you are 50 or older.
- Pick your Current Tax Rate (%) and your Expected Retirement Tax Rate (%) from the bracket lists.
- Set the Expected Annual Return (%).
- Choose your situation in Filing Status & Income to see the Roth eligibility message for 2026.
- Read the Roth and traditional cards, the winner banner and the comparison table. Try different retirement rates to find the break-even.
What this IRA calculator shows
Equal-cost comparison
Both accounts cost you the same take-home pay each year. The traditional side invests the grossed-up pre-tax amount, which is why it can come out ahead if your retirement rate is lower.
After-tax value
Roth value is its full balance. Traditional value is its balance times one minus your retirement tax rate.
Winner banner
Shows the dollar difference and which account wins for the rates you entered, or a tie if they are equal.
2026 Roth income check
A dropdown covers single and married-filing-jointly modified AGI ranges. Single is $153,000 to $168,000 for the phase-out and joint is $242,000 to $252,000.
Side-by-side table
Compares deduction, withdrawal tax, required distributions, early access, balances, after-tax value and total tax paid.
Rate-sensitive results
Change only the retirement rate and the winner can flip, which shows how the choice depends on your tax future.
Who uses it, and for what
- A young professional in a low bracket. At 12% now and a possible 22% later, enter both and see why a Roth often looks attractive early in a career.
- A mid-career saver at 24%. If you expect to live on less in retirement, test a lower retirement rate. The FIRE Number Calculator can help you estimate your future spending first.
- Someone near the Roth income limit. Use the filing and income dropdown to see whether you are in the full, partial or no-direct-contribution range for 2026.
- A worker splitting savings between accounts. If your employer offers a 401(k), compare with the 401k Contribution Optimizer before deciding how much goes to an IRA.
Tips for using the comparison
- Use your marginal bracket, not your average rate. The Tax Bracket Visualizer can show which bracket your last dollar falls in.
- Retirement rates are hard to predict. Run the comparison at two or three possible rates and look at the range.
- Required minimum distributions, Social Security taxation and pension income can raise your retirement rate above what you expect.
- Traditional IRA deductibility can be limited if you or your spouse are covered by a workplace plan. This tool assumes the full deduction.
- Limits and income ranges change. The 2026 figures here come from the IRS announcement. Check the current year before you contribute.
Is it safe? Privacy and limits
The comparison runs in your browser, and the numbers you choose are not sent or stored. Reloading the page resets everything. The model uses one flat tax rate now and one later, yearly compounding and no fees, state tax, phase-outs, Social Security effects or contribution-limit checks on the grossed-up amount. It is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice. A tax professional can look at your full situation.
Roth vs traditional IRA calculator FAQ
Neither wins in every case. With equal take-home cost, a Roth comes out ahead when your tax rate in retirement is higher than your rate today, a traditional IRA comes out ahead when it is lower, and they tie when the two are equal. Other factors matter too: Roth has no required minimum distributions during your lifetime, and traditional contributions may not be deductible if you have a workplace plan. Use the calculator to see the size of the gap for your own rates.
It gives both the same cost in take-home pay. The Roth side invests the contribution you typed. The traditional side invests that amount divided by one minus your current tax rate, which is the pre-tax dollars that would leave you with the same take-home cost after the deduction. Both grow at your return, and the traditional balance is then reduced by your retirement tax rate. The result is the after-tax value of each at retirement. It is a model, not a tax return.
For 2026, the IRS limit is $7,500 for an IRA, with an extra $1,100 catch-up at 50 and older, for $8,600. The limit applies across your traditional and Roth IRAs combined, and you need earned income at least equal to your contribution. Note that the model's traditional side can invest more than the limit because of the gross-up. Treat that as a modelling assumption, as the extra tax savings would be invested elsewhere. Check the IRS page for the current year.
For 2026, the IRS phase-out range is $153,000 to $168,000 of modified adjusted gross income for single filers and heads of household, and $242,000 to $252,000 for married couples filing jointly. Below the range you can contribute the full amount, within it you can contribute a reduced amount and above it you cannot contribute directly. The dropdown in this tool reflects those numbers, but MAGI has its own definition, so check IRS Publication 590-A for the details.
You cannot contribute directly, but you may have other routes. The best known is the backdoor Roth, where you contribute to a nondeductible traditional IRA and convert it. The pro-rata rule can make that taxable if you already hold pre-tax IRA money, so the details matter. Some 401(k) plans also offer a Roth option with no income limit. This calculator only warns you about direct contributions. Speak with a tax professional before using a conversion strategy.
No. It uses a single federal bracket today and a single bracket in retirement. State income tax, which can differ a lot if you move, is not modelled. Neither is the taxation of Social Security benefits, which can be triggered by traditional IRA withdrawals, or the effect of required minimum distributions on your bracket. If those could apply to you, your retirement rate may be higher than your first guess, so test a higher figure.
They are annual withdrawals the IRS requires from traditional IRAs once you reach a certain age, currently 73 for some people and 75 for those born in 1960 or later. Roth IRAs have no required distributions for the original owner. The comparison table notes this difference, but the dollar results do not model withdrawals. If you may not need the money, the lack of RMDs is a real advantage of the Roth that does not show in the balances.
It is free, needs no account and works in your browser, so the figures you enter stay on your device and are cleared on reload. It uses simple assumptions and covers US federal tax only. Use it to understand the tradeoff and to try rate scenarios, not as personal tax advice. For a decision that involves large sums, conversions or an income near the limits, ask a qualified tax professional.